3 Key Objectives for a Return Policy

3 Key Objectives for a Return Policy
a2b hero background
Written by
a2b Fulfillment
Published on
March 22, 2021

According to a report released in January 2021 by the National Retail Federation and Appriss Retail, consumers returned an estimated $428 billion in merchandise to retailers last year. That equates to approximately 10.6 percent of total retail sales in the year 2020.

“Last year, we saw an increase in returns of online purchases as the pandemic forced more consumers to shop online,” said Mark Mathews, NRF’s vice president of research development and industry analysis. “Retailers view the return process as an opportunity to further engage with customers, as it provides additional points of contact for retailers to enhance the overall consumer experience.”

The prevention and later handling of the returns can really have a big impact on an e-commerce retailer’s bottom line.

A retailer’s return policy could be costing them big time with regards to lost sales. Another study by e-commerce data specialists, Granify, showed a strong return policy as the largest influence for online shoppers of clothing and apparel. In fact, a solid return policy and positive customer reviews actually outranked price with most customers. There could be numerous reasons for a return (customer can’t hold and feel the product prior to purchase, buyer’s remorse, etc.), but what’s for certain these days is consumers need a clear path for making a return before they even make their purchase online.

The pandemic has forced many retailers to completely change their approach to return policies. But have no fear. Based on our experience within the order fulfillment realm, we can help you mine for potential gold within those hills of returned packages.

Below we outline three key objectives to consider for your return policies that hopefully help avoid a holiday hangover:

1) Know your “true” cost for returns – Everything starts with calculating costs. Underestimate your costs and you may think you can sustain a higher level of returns, while still achieving your financial goals. Overestimate your costs and you might provide a less friendly customer service level that could mean lower sales. Consider all the cost elements: customer service, shipping and receiving, processing returned goods, refurbishment, recycling product, disposal of returned items and costs for storage.

2) Good Feedback and On-going Process Improvement – To have a strong returns program you have to understand why they are occurring in the first place. Buyer’s remorse is a big one. Oftentimes, products fail to meet customer’s expectations.

Here’s a few questions you might ask about your business: What expectations are you setting with your customer? Are you delivering on product promises? Are enough items available? Can you fulfill shipping and delivery times?

Your business can refine the product promise message to more accurately shape the customer’s expectation. A solid order management system allows the customer service agent and shopping cart user to know if the product is actually in stock. A fulfillment center with same-day processing strategy will reduce time from order to delivery. Proper placement of logistics operations can reduce time in transit, and lower shipping costs. Define where the majority of your customers are buying from and position your fulfillment operation so that the majority can be reached within 2 days.

3) Build your tribe of loyal followers. Customer satisfaction and loyalty are key elements in a returns strategy. Several options exist for the actual handling of customer returns:

  1. Just keep it – If it’s a low cost item, sometimes it’s easier to just avoid the physical return and allow the customer to retain the item.
  2. Have the Customer Pay – Perhaps the most popular choice; however, consider adding a spin. Often it’s less expensive for the retailer, especially via a fulfillment partner, to transport a returned package. As such, offer your customers a prepaid shipping label for a fee that’s a win-win for all parties. The customer pays less and avoids many of the hassles of a return.
  3. Free to the Customer – More favorable for the customer but difficult for most retailers to entertain. If you’re looking to score points with the customer through this method, make sure to initiate the return via a return label program at optimal pricing versus reimbursing the customer at retail shipping rates. This is a ‘Gold in them Hills’ option because everyone is happy and the Marketer can introduce it only after the Save-the-Sale attempts have failed.

But it doesn’t end there. By controlling returns, retailers proactively notify customers of return status, dramatically reducing customer service calls. Techniques include email confirmations in the following areas: package delivery, arrival to the warehouse, when processing occurs and once the credit or refund is issued. These are little details that can go a long way to improving customer satisfaction. And they reduce customer service costs. At the end of the day, you want to build loyal customers who communicate positive experiences – thus creating credibility with new customers.

Subscribe to newsletter

Subscribe to receive the latest blog posts to your inbox every week.

By subscribing you agree to with our Privacy Policy.
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

Now it will work - Quickly, Correctly, and With Care.

We don’t see boxes.
We see people.

Fulfilling Brand promises, for 23 years and counting.

Start Your Journey